中国比较文学学会会刊 1984年创刊 由中国比较文学学会和上海外国语大学联合主办 ISSN 1006-6101 CN
  • 中国人文社科核心期刊
  • 中国学术期刊综合评价数据库来源期刊
  • 中文社会科学引文数据库来源期刊

中国比较文学 ›› 2025, Vol. 0 ›› Issue (3): 220-229.

• 翻译研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

重读韦勒克——兼论推陈出新与学术传承

钱兆明   

  • 出版日期:2025-07-20 发布日期:2025-07-16
  • 作者简介:钱兆明,美国新奥尔良大学教授。研究方向:现代主义诗歌、诗学,跨文化、跨学科研究。电子邮箱:zqian2026@outlook.com。

A Rereading of Wellek’s “The Crisis of Comparative Literature”

Qian Zhaoming   

  • Online:2025-07-20 Published:2025-07-16

摘要: 推陈出新是一种创新型的学术传承方式。重读韦勒克的“比较文学的危机”和希里斯·米勒的“比较文学的(语言)危机”,会发现后者为推陈出新、学术传承之一例。重读韦勒克与沃伦的《文学理论》和帕洛夫的《虚薄》,会发现后者为推陈出新、学术传承之又一例。米勒文中所谓“(语言)危机”实指“文化帝国主义”造成的“文化鸿沟”。通过批判西方中心主义,米勒推出强调读懂“弱势语言”的比较文学的新标准。作为俄国形式主义奠基人雅各布森的弟子,韦勒克在《文学理论》中将俄国形式主义阐释得淋漓尽致。帕洛夫最早从《文学理论》读到雅各布森,60余年反复研读雅各布森,逝世前出版《虚薄》,终于在俄国形式主义的基础上推陈出新,开创了解析20世纪与21世纪现代主义诗歌的微诗学。

关键词: 韦勒克, 米勒, 帕洛夫, 俄国形式主义, 推陈出新型学术传承

Abstract: “Make-it-new” is an innovative approach to academic inheritance. A rereading of Wellek’s “The Crisis of Comparative Literature” along with Hillis Miller’s “The (Language) Crisis of Comparative Literature” reveals the latter to be an illustration of “making-it-new.” A rereading of Wellek and Warren’s Literary Theory along with Perloff’s Infrathin brings out “make-it-new” insights in the latter. Miller’s “(Language) Crisis” alludes to “cultural gap” created by “cultural imperialism.” Through criticizing Western-centrism, Miller initiates a new criterion for comparative literature. As Russian formalist leader Jacobson’s disciple, Wellek is expected to contribute to Literary Theory accurate and insightful interpretation of Jacobson. Perloff read about Jacobson in Literary Theory. She kept rereading Jacobson for 60 years until 2022 when she launched in Infrathin micropoetics by making Russian formalism new.

Key words: René Wellek, Hillis Miller, Majorie Perloff, Russian formalism, making-it-new approach to academic inheritance